What Can I Not Tell My Therapist? Secrets, Boundaries, and What Really Matters in Therapy

• Share

Therapy is supposed to be a safe space. But if you’ve ever sat in a chair, hands sweating, wondering whether to say that thing-the one that makes you feel ashamed, weird, or terrified-you’re not alone. The question isn’t just what can I not tell my therapist? It’s: Will they judge me? Will they think I’m broken? Will they tell someone?

The truth? Most therapists have heard it all. And they’re trained not to react with shock, disgust, or moral judgment. But that doesn’t mean everything you think, feel, or do is automatically fair game to share. There are limits-not because your therapist is hiding something from you, but because therapy is built on boundaries. And those boundaries exist to protect both of you.

What You Can Absolutely Say (Even If It Feels Awful)

Let’s clear the air first: there’s almost nothing you can say that will make your therapist walk out. People come in with thoughts they’ve never voiced aloud. Thoughts about hurting themselves. Thoughts about hurting others. Thoughts about cheating on their partner, stealing from their boss, or wishing their parent had died. Thoughts about being turned on by someone they shouldn’t be. Thoughts about hating their child. Thoughts about enjoying the pain of others.

And therapists? They don’t blink. They don’t gasp. They don’t write you off. Why? Because therapy isn’t about being good. It’s about being real. The goal isn’t to impress. It’s to understand.

One client told her therapist she fantasized about stabbing her ex during their divorce. The therapist didn’t call the police. She didn’t say, “That’s crazy.” She asked: “What would that fantasy have done for you in that moment?” The answer? Control. Power. Relief from helplessness. That’s what mattered-not the image in her head, but the emotion behind it.

If you’re scared to say something because you think it’s “too dark,” “too weird,” or “too wrong,” that’s exactly the thing you need to say. Your therapist isn’t there to fix your morality. They’re there to help you understand your mind.

What You Shouldn’t Say (And Why)

Now, here’s the flip side. There are things you shouldn’t say-not because they’re bad, but because they break the structure of therapy.

Don’t give your therapist a personal history you didn’t live. Example: “My dad used to beat me when I was a kid.” If you didn’t experience that, don’t say it. Therapists don’t treat fictional trauma. They treat real pain. Fabricating stories-even if you think it’ll make you seem more “valid”-undermines trust. And trust is the foundation.

Don’t try to “test” your therapist. “What would you do if I told you I killed someone?” “Would you still like me if I was a pedophile?” These aren’t deep questions. They’re power plays. They’re designed to see if your therapist is “real” or “fake.” But therapy isn’t a performance. It’s a relationship built on honesty, not manipulation.

Don’t use therapy as a venting session for revenge. “I hate my boss. I wish he’d get fired.” “My sister is a liar. I hope she loses everything.” If you’re only using therapy to feed anger, you’re not healing-you’re rehearsing. Therapists can help you process anger. But they can’t help you if you keep pouring fuel on the fire.

Don’t ask your therapist to be your friend. “Can we hang out after sessions?” “Can I text you when I’m lonely?” “Can we be Instagram friends?” These aren’t boundary issues-they’re relationship issues. Therapists aren’t friends. They’re guides. If you need friendship, build it outside therapy. Therapy is for healing, not companionship.

When Silence Is Safer Than Speech

There are moments when not saying something isn’t about fear-it’s about safety.

If you’re currently in danger-like being abused, threatened, or trapped in a violent relationship-your therapist is legally required to report it in many places. In India, therapists aren’t mandatory reporters for adult abuse unless it involves minors or imminent risk of death. But in the U.S., Canada, or the U.K., that rule changes. So if you’re sharing something that could trigger a report, ask: “Will you have to tell someone if I say this?”

Some therapists will say, “I can’t promise confidentiality if someone’s in danger.” Others will say, “I’ll try to protect your privacy unless the law forces me to act.” Either way, you deserve to know. Don’t assume. Ask.

And if you’re worried about legal consequences? Say: “I’m not going to hurt anyone, but I did something illegal and I’m scared.” That’s different from saying, “I’m planning to hurt someone.” The first is a cry for help. The second is a red flag.

What Your Therapist Can’t Do

Therapy isn’t magic. And your therapist isn’t a superhero. They can’t:

• Change your life for you
• Make you feel better instantly
• Give you advice like a life coach
• Fix your marriage, job, or family
• Be your confidant outside sessions
• Promise you’ll get over it

What they can do is help you see patterns. Help you name feelings. Help you understand why you react the way you do. Help you build tools-not solutions.

So if you’re waiting for your therapist to tell you to leave your partner, quit your job, or cut off your family-you’re setting yourself up for disappointment. They won’t give you answers. They’ll help you find your own.

What Happens If You Lie?

Lying in therapy isn’t a moral failure. It’s a survival tactic. You’re not lying because you’re bad. You’re lying because you’re scared. Scared of being seen. Scared of being rejected. Scared of being labeled.

But here’s the thing: lies in therapy don’t stay hidden. They show up. In your sleep. In your anger. In your panic attacks. In your inability to trust anyone-even your therapist.

One man came to therapy for anxiety. He said he was stressed at work. After six months, he admitted he was hiding his HIV status from his family. He’d been terrified they’d blame him. But his anxiety didn’t go away. Why? Because the secret was eating him alive. Once he told his therapist the truth, the panic attacks dropped by 70% in three weeks.

Therapy doesn’t punish lies. It reveals them. And once they’re out in the open, they lose their power.

What’s the Point of Therapy If I Can’t Be Fully Honest?

Here’s the real answer: you can be fully honest. You just have to know the rules.

Therapy isn’t about telling your therapist every thought that pops into your head. It’s about telling them the thoughts that are holding you back. The ones that keep you up at night. The ones that make you feel alone. The ones you’ve buried because you thought no one would understand.

And guess what? They already understand. Not because they’ve read a textbook. But because they’ve sat with hundreds of people who felt exactly like you.

You don’t need to be perfect. You don’t need to be brave. You just need to show up. Even if you’re shaking. Even if you cry. Even if you say, “I don’t know what to say.”

That’s enough.

When to Walk Away

Not all therapists are right for you. And that’s okay.

If your therapist:

• Shames you for your feelings
• Pushes their religion or politics on you
• Never asks follow-up questions
• Acts bored or distracted
• Breaks confidentiality without warning
• Refuses to answer your questions about their training or methods

Then it’s time to leave. Therapy should feel like a warm room. Not a cold courtroom.

Find someone who listens more than they talk. Who doesn’t fix. Who doesn’t judge. Who lets you sit in silence without rushing you. That’s the kind of therapist you need.

Final Thought: You’re Not Broken

Therapy isn’t for people who are “crazy.” It’s for people who are tired. Tired of pretending. Tired of explaining. Tired of feeling like they’re the only one who thinks this way.

You don’t need to tell your therapist everything. But you do need to tell them the truth-about what’s hurting you, what’s scaring you, what’s keeping you stuck.

And if you’re still wondering what you can’t say? Here’s the answer: you can say anything. Just don’t lie to yourself.

• Tags
• therapist confidentiality
• what not to tell therapist
• therapy secrets
• mental health boundaries
• therapy honesty